Wide Dynamic Range Vegetation Index for Remote Quantification of Biophysical Characteristics of Vegetation

doi:10.1078/0176-1617-01176

Journal of Plant Physiology

Volume 161, Issue 2, 2004, Pages 165-173

https://doi.org/10.1078/0176-1617-01176 Get rights and content

Summary

The Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) is widely used for monitoring, analyzing, and mapping temporal and spatial distributions of physiological and biophysical characteristics of vegetation. It is well documented that the NDVI approaches saturation asymptotically under conditions of moderate-to-high aboveground biomass. While reflectance in the red region (ρ_red) exhibits a nearly flat response once the leaf area index (LAI) exceeds 2, the near infrared (NIR) reflectance (ρ_NIR) continue to respond significantly to changes in moderate-to-high vegetation density (LAI from 2 to 6) in crops. However, this higher sensitivity of the ρ_NIR has little effect on NDVI values once the ρ_NIR exceeds 30 %. In this paper a simple modification of the NDVI was proposed. The Wide Dynamic Range Vegetation Index, WDRVI = (a * ρ_NIR-ρ_red)/(a * ρ_NIR+ρ_red), where the weighting coefficient a has a value of 0.1–0.2, increases correlation with vegetation fraction by linearizing the relationship for typical wheat, soybean, and maize canopies. The sensitivity of the WDRVI to moderate-to-high LAI (between 2 and 6) was at least three times greater than that of the NDVI. By enhancing the dynamic range while using the same bands as the NDVI, the WDRVI enables a more robust characterization of crop physiological and phenological characteristics. Although this index needs further evaluation, the linear relationship with vegetation fraction and much higher sensitivity to change in LAI will be especially valuable for precision agriculture and monitoring vegetation status under conditions of moderate-to-high density. It is anticipated that the new index will complement the NDVI and other vegetation indices that are based on the red and NIR spectral bands.

References (33)

F. Baret et al.
Potentials and limits of vegetation indices for LAI and PAR assessment
Remote Sens Environ
(1991)
J.M. Chen et al.
Retrieving leaf area index of boreal conifer forests using Landsat TM images
Remote Sens Environ
(1996)
C.S.T. Daughtry et al.
Estimating corn leaf chlorophyll status from leaf and canopy reflectance
Remote Sens Environ
(2000)
A.A. Gitelson et al.
MODIS NDVI Optimization to Fit the AVHRR Data Series – Spectral Considerations
Remote Sens Environ
(1998)
A.A. Gitelson et al.
Use of green channel in remote sensing of global vegetation from EOS-MODIS
Remote Sens Environ
(1996)
A.A. Gitelson et al.
Novel algorithms for remote estimation of vegetation fraction
Remote Sens Environ
(2002)
A.R. Huete
A soil-adjusted vegetation index (SAVI)
Remote Sens Environ
(1988)
A.R. Huete et al.
A comparison of vegetation indices over a global set of TM images for EOSMODIS
Remote Sens Environ
(1997)
A.R. Huete et al.
Overview of radiometric and biophysical performance of the MODIS vegetation indices
Remote Sens Environ
(2002)
R.D. Jackson et al.
Bidirectional calibration results for 11 Spectralon and 16 BaSO4 reference reflectance panels
Remote Sens Environ
(1992)

M.S. Moran et al.

Opportunities and limitations for image-based remote sensing in precision crop management

Remote Sens Environ

(1997)

R.B. Myneni et al.

Global products of vegetation leaf area and fraction absorbed PAR from year one of MODIS data

Remote Sens Environ

(2002)

J.-L. Roujean et al.

Estimating PAR absorbed by vegetation from bi-directional reflectance measurements

Remote Sens Environ

(1995)

M.M. Verstraete et al.

Potential and limitations of information extraction on the terrestrial biosphere from satellite remote sensing

Remote Sens Environ

(1996)

G. Asrar et al.

Estimating absorbed photosynthetic radiation and leaf area index from spectral reflectance in wheat

Agron J

(1984)

F. Baret et al.

TSAVI: a vegetation index, which minimizes soil brightness effects on LAI and APAR estimation

Cited by (877)

A chlorophyll-constrained semi-empirical model for estimating leaf area index using a red-edge vegetation index
2024, Computers and Electronics in Agriculture
The parameter of leaf area index (LAI) provides valuable information about plant growth. Most remote sensing methods for estimating LAI are based on the vegetation indices (VIs) in the visible and near-infrared (VNIR) spectral regions. Recently, these VIs calculated with one or more bands in the red-edge region become popular in estimating LAI. Since the reflectance in the red-edge spectral region is sensitive to both LAI and leaf chlorophyll content (LCC), most red-edge-based VIs (such as normalized difference red edge index, NDRE) should be used to estimate the canopy chlorophyll content (the product of LAI and LCC) in theory. When applying NDRE to estimating LAI alone, their relationship is affected by the variation in LCC. To mitigate the LCC effect on LAI estimation using NDRE, this study proposed a chlorophyll-constrained semi-empirical model (CSE). The coefficients of the CSE model were determined from the simulated dataset based on radiative transfer models, and hence were not dependent on measured data. The performance of the CSE model on LAI estimation was evaluated using simulated and measured datasets, including a crop dataset collected in China and a multi-ecosystem dataset obtained from the National Ecological Observatory Network (NEON). The results showed that the root mean square error (RMSE) obtained by the CSE model ranged from 0.58 to 0.72 m^2/m² for the simulated and measured datasets. In particular, the CSE model also exhibited wide generality across multiple vegetation types for the NEON dataset, with the RMSE in the range of 0.33–0.86 m^2/m². In comparison, without considering the LCC effect, the model would lead to clear underestimation or overestimation of LAI (RMSE = 1.26–2.11 m^2/m²). These findings improved our understanding of the LCC effects on universal LAI predictive models and would facilitate the accurate mapping of LAI over large regions for monitoring plant growth status.
A SIF-based approach for quantifying canopy photosynthesis by simulating the fraction of open PSII reaction centers (q<inf>L</inf>)
2024, Remote Sensing of Environment
Advances in retrieval of solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF) provide a promising and independent approach for quantifying gross primary production (GPP) across spatial scales. Recent studies have highlighted the prominent role of q_L, the fraction of open Photosystem II (PSII) reaction centers, in mechanistically modeling GPP from remote sensing SIF. However, due to the limited availability of simulated and experimental data, a comprehensive understanding of q_L responses to environmental and physiological variations has yet to emerge, and as a consequence, prediction of q_L across leaf and canopy scales is still in an early stage. Based on a global sensitivity analysis of a recently developed mechanical model of photosynthesis, we find that the broadband total SIF emitted from PSII (SIF_{TOT_FULL_PSII}) and leaf temperature (T_Leaf) are the two major predictors of q_L. A leaf-level instrument is designed to obtain concurrent measurements of q_L, SIF_{TOT_FULL_PSII}, and T_Leaf over a wide range of environmental conditions. From these measurements, we show that q_L can be modelled as a hyperbolic function of SIF_{TOT_FULL_PSII} with only one temperature-related parameter m which increases with temperature, but decreases rapidly as temperatures exceed the optimum temperature. It is suggested that m can be mathematically modelled by a peaked function. The results of the leaf-level experiments on winter wheat demonstrate that the proposed model predicts q_L with high accuracy (R² ≥ 0.91, rRMSE ≤ 8.46%) under diverse light and temperature conditions. The essential steps necessary to apply it at canopy scale, including estimating the escape fraction, removing fluorescence emitted from Photosystem I, and reconstructing SIF_{TOT_FULL_PSII} from top-of-canopy (TOC) narrowband SIF, are also presented. Our results confirm that estimated GPP using SIF-informed q_L agrees well with measured GPP at a winter wheat site (R² = 0.81, rRMSE = 12.03%). The key benefit of SIF-informed approach is that SIF_{TOT_FULL_PSII} provides critical information on the collective influence of the sub-canopy light environment on q_L, avoiding the requirement to explicitly estimate q_L at different canopy depths, potentially promoting the ability of SIF to mechanistically quantify photosynthetic CO₂ assimilation at large scales.
Investigation into the long-term response of vegetation to dam operation in a large river using Landsat time-series data
2024, Journal of Hydrology
Vegetation is an important component of riparian ecosystems, providing fundamental habitats for numerous species. Over the past few decades, as more and more large river systems have been heavily dammed, the vegetation communities in downstream floodplains have potentially been affected, but the vegetation response to this type of human-mediated disturbance is not well known. In this study, the long-term vegetation dynamics in a large river, the Middle Yangtze River, were investigated using Landsat time-series data, and the focus was placed on the relict mid-channel bars downstream of the Three Gorges Dam (TGD). To reveal the vegetation dynamics, a phenological metric, maturity average vegetation index (MAVI), was defined based on the vegetation index during the maturity phase. Simultaneously, an unsupervised change detection method was developed to identify flood inundation areas by differencing water index value from pre- and post-flood Landsat images. The main findings are as follows: (i) post-TGD flood events exerted a more detrimental impact on the floodplain vegetation compared to pre-TGD events. For some bars, the flood impact on vegetation converted from positive to negative in response to a ∼ 90 % decline in sediment concentration post-TGD, while for some other bars the negative impact was further exacerbated; (ii) The MAVI-cumulative curves for zones under different elevations approached each other in response to a 12-year absence of episodic overbank flooding after the TGD, and for stable bars the curves converged in a time scale of ∼ 10 years, exhibiting diminished vegetation heterogeneity thereafter; (iii) Of the methods for deriving vegetation dynamics and inundation pattern, the vegetation index, OSAVI, was suitable for characterising the phenology of perennial reed species, and the unsupervised change detection method can generate an accurate flood inundation map for mid-channel bars with limited ground truth data. Overall, the vegetation responses to the TGD operation can help understanding the dam impact on vegetation and facilitate the floodplain restoration projects in the heavily dammed fluvial system.
Quantifying canopy nitrogen of Aman rice utilizing multi-temporal unmanned aerial systems
2024, Remote Sensing Applications: Society and Environment
Timely and precise monitoring of canopy nutrient status is critical for rice production. Advancement in unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) sensing technology has great potential in monitoring and assessing crops. This study quantified canopy nitrogen (N) using a multispectral sensing in a field experiment. The experiment comprised seven treatments including different doses and sources of N. The UAV data was collected at different phenological stages from three consecutive rice seasons e.g., Boro (Winter, 2020–21), Aman (monsoon 2021), and Boro (Winter, 2021–22). The popular rice varieties Binadhan-7 and BRRI dhan29 were cultivated for Aman and Boro rice, respectively. The vegetation indices (VIs) increased with the growth of crops and were the highest at 50 DAT in all the treatments. The RD with 25 % more N showed significantly higher values for normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), chlorophyll vegetation index (CVI), simple ratio (SR), optimized soil adjusted vegetation index (OSAVI), and green normalized difference vegetation index (GNDVI) leading to excessive vegetative growth. The model for estimating canopy N percent was based on NDVI and observed nitrogen with a R² value of 0.74. The model was validated against N percent of Boro rice (2020–21) with a R² value of 0.78 and RMSE 0.09 and N percent of Boro rice (2021–22) R² value of 0.75 and RMSE 0.10. In biochar treatment, the highest level of canopy N was observed, followed by cow dung and USG treatments. The study revealed that 25 % more N than RD instigates vegetative growth and canopy nitrogen was highest in biochar treatment.
Estimation of aboveground biomass of senescence grassland in China's arid region using multi-source data
2024, Science of the Total Environment
Aboveground Biomass (AGB) in the grassland senescence period is a key indicator for assessing grassland fire risk and autumnal pasture carrying capacity. Despite the advancement of remote sensing in rapid monitoring of AGB on a regional scale, accurately monitoring AGB during the senescence period in vast arid areas remains a major challenge. Using remote sensing, environmental data, and 356 samples of grassland senescence period AGB data, this study utilizes the Gram-Schmidt Pan Sharpening (GS) method, multivariate selection methods, and machine learning algorithms (RF, SVM, and BP_ANN) to construct a model for AGB during senescence grassland, and applies the optimal model to analyze spatio-temporal pattern changes in AGB from 2000 to 2021 in arid regions. The results indicate that the GS method effectively enhances the correlation between measured AGB and vegetation indices, reducing model error to some extent; The accuracy of grassland AGB inversion models based on a single vegetation index is low (0.03 ≤ |R| ≤ 0.63), while the RF model constructed with multiple variables selected by the Boruta algorithm is the optimal model for estimating AGB in arid regions during the senescence period (R² = 0.71, RMSE = 519.74 kg/ha); In the span of 22 years, the annual average AGB in the senescence period of arid regions was 1413.85 kg/ha, with regions of higher AGB primarily located in the northeast and southwest of the study area. The area experiencing an increase in AGB during the senescence period (79.97 %) was significantly larger than that with decreased AGB (20.03 %).
Improved estimation of SPAD values in walnut leaves by combining spectral, texture, and structural information from UAV-based multispectral image
2024, Scientia Horticulturae
An important measure to describe the physiological status of vegetation is the chlorophyll concentration of the vegetation. For managing fields in precision agriculture, monitoring walnut growth, and estimating production, accurate determination of chlorophyll content is crucial. Spectral indices play a crucial role in the non-destructive and efficient monitoring of crop physiological parameters, especially in estimating chlorophyll content. However, spectral indices have low sensitivity to high chlorophyll levels and are susceptible to interference from background signals, which may result in decreased stability of the model. The unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) captures high-resolution images that contain abundant spatial information, including texture and structural information. These spatial information can reflect crop canopy structure, may help to improve the estimation precision of crop chlorophyll content. However, research on utilizing drone-based spatial information for estimating crop chlorophyll content is relatively limited. The aim of this study is to explore the potential of integrating spectral, textural, and structural information to improve the accuracy of walnut leaf chlorophyll content estimation. This study used a drone equipped with a multispectral camera to capture images of walnut tree canopies. Based on these images, we extracted 17 spectral indices, 8 texture indices, and 5 structural indices. Then, we applied the Boruta algorithm to select the optimal spectral, texture, and structural indices, as well as their combinations. Finally, the SPAD (Soil and plant analyzer development) values estimation model for walnut leaves was established using the Decision Tree Regression (DTR), Random Forest Regression (RFR), and Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) methods. The research findings indicate that the accuracy of SPAD values estimation model constructed by combining remote sensing indices (spectral indices (SI), texture indices (TI) and structural indices (STI) are combined in pairwise or in full) is better than that of single remote sensing indices. In the combined remote sensing indices models, the accuracy of the model constructed by the pairwise combination of three remote sensing indices is relatively limited. However, when using the combination of spectral indices, texture indices, and structural indices, the estimation accuracy of SPAD values for walnut leaves can be effectively improved, and this combination is considered the best way to estimate SPAD values. Furthermore, among the trio of SPAD values estimation models considered (namely DTR, RFR, and XGBoost), the XGBoost model exhibited superior performance. Notably, when combining SI+TI+STI in the construction of the XGBoost model, it demonstrated the highest level of accuracy in estimating SPAD values (Training: R²_T =0.95, RMSE_T=1.08; Validation: R²_v = 0.72, RMSE_v=2.13). The findings of this research elucidate that the incorporation of spatial information from UAV multispectral imagery facilitates the monitoring of physiological parameters in walnut trees. By integrating the spatial and spectral information of UAV multispectral imagery, a feasible and accurate estimation method has been provided for monitoring the chlorophyll content in walnut leaves.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text