Toasting changes both the quantity and the quality of the extractable substances in the oak wood of barrels used for the aging of fine wines and spirits. Mastery and repeatability of toasting are vital in the production of quality barrels to be used for the aging of wines and spirits. In this study, we show that it is possible for a given cooperage to differentiate barrel toasting levels by analyzing a certain number of volatile and semivolatile compounds resulting from the thermal degradation of oak. Toasted wood components, which can be extracted by the wines or spirits during the aging process, are normally analyzed after the wood has soaked in standard alcoholic solutions and can be used to control the intensity of the wood toasting. The results of the comparative analysis presented in this work show that headspace analysis with a microextractive method using a stationary polydimethylsiloxane type phase is a promising technique for analyzing toasted oak wood from barrels. It is easier to use than the traditional maceration and extraction method and provides similar information.