Abstract
Background and goals Hailstorms pose a significant threat to viticulture, yet their impact on grapevine performance in the following season and the efficacy of adaptive management strategies remain largely unexplored. This study aimed to quantify the effects of a severe hailstorm on bud viability and fruitfulness and to assess pruning strategies to mitigate yield losses in the subsequent year.
Methods and key findings After a hailstorm that severely damaged the current-season crop in a Vitis vinifera L. cv. Glera vineyard, wood injury and bud viability were evaluated based on wind direction and canopy exposure (west- versus east-facing). Hail damage was variable within the canopy, with more injury and bud mortality on the west-facing side. Although the intrinsic fruitfulness of surviving buds remained unaffected, the presence of necrotic buds led to a notable reduction in inflorescence primordia per node in west-facing canes (from +0.20 to +0.74 inflorescence primordia per node). Subsequently, four pruning strategies were compared: standard pruning based on a permanent cordon and six fruiting canes, three west-oriented and three east-oriented; an adapted pruning that retained fruiting canes only on the less-damaged east-facing side; a reference treatment retaining all canes on the most damaged west-facing side; and delayed pruning at bud swelling, allowing discrimination between viable and non-viable buds. West-facing retained fruiting canes exhibited lower yield than east-facing (0.65 kg/fruiting cane versus 1.24 kg/fruiting cane); however, at whole-vine level, yield was only partially affected due to compensatory mechanisms. Delayed pruning enhanced yield (+18%) by increasing crop contribution from the west-facing fruiting canes (+48%).
Conclusions and significance Our findings indicate that in mid- to late-season hail events, subsequent year crop recovery is primarily driven by the rate of buds escaping fatal injuries, rather than by a reduction in bud fruitfulness. Pruning adaptations that promote the retention of canes with viable buds could be crucial to enhance yield recovery after severe hail damage.
Introduction
Hailstorms are among the most destructive meteorological threats to agriculture. With climate change, there is growing interest in understanding how convective storms and hail-producing systems might change in terms of frequency, intensity, and spatial distribution. Although current evidence does not consistently show a systematic increase in the total number of hail events, several recent studies predict a rise in high-intensity hailstorms, marked by larger hailstone sizes and significant destructive potential (Battaglioli et al. 2025, Kahraman et al. 2025, Kunz et al. 2025). Southern and central Europe seem to be particularly vulnerable to such occurrences.
The Mediterranean basin has been increasingly recognized as a hotspot for severe convective storms, primarily due to the combined effects of rising sea surface temperatures, increased atmospheric moisture, and strong thermal gradients between land and sea (Raupach et al. 2021, Kunz et al. 2025). Within this context, viticulture stands out as one of the agricultural sectors most vulnerable to hail-related risks. A significant portion of European vineyards are situated in regions that are highly susceptible to severe convective activity, including northern Italy, southern France, Spain, and parts of central Europe (Giaiotti et al. 2003, Raupach et al. 2021, Petit et al. 2023, Zhou and Vilar-Zanón 2025). Simultaneously, modern wine regions are also experiencing an increase in hailstorm occurrences. In North America, the United States Great Plains and California’s viticultural regions have historically suffered significant agricultural losses due to hail (Raupach et al. 2021). Similarly, long-term climatological analyses for the Southern Hemisphere indicate regionally-increasing periods that are favorable to hailstorm formation, particularly along the southern and eastern Australian coasts, where the wine industry is experiencing comparable issues (Raupach et al. 2021, Ibbotson 2022, Rogiers et al. 2022, Battaglioli et al. 2025).
Despite the significance of this issue, the scientific literature on the effects of hail damage on grapevine physiology and productivity is surprisingly limited. To date, only a handful of peer-reviewed studies have experimentally assessed hail effects in vineyards. Among these, one study examined the effects of a natural hail event that occurred 4 wk after bloom, in Mediterranean conditions (Petoumenou et al. 2019). However, in that instance the hailstorm was of moderate intensity, causing limited canopy damage and no significant yield reduction. In response to this risk, some wine regions have implemented direct protective strategies, most notably anti-hail netting systems. Recent research has documented significant advancements in the design and application of hail-protection nets, including evaluations of their effects on canopy microclimate, vine physiology, and grape quality (Forte et al. 2022, Ruland et al. 2023, Domanda et al. 2024, Pallotti et al. 2025). Although these systems can be highly effective in preventing physical damage, their adoption is often limited due to the high costs of installation and maintenance. As a result, they are generally confined to high-value vineyards or areas that are particularly exposed. Meanwhile, indirect risk-management strategies such as hail insurance schemes are widely employed to mitigate the economic impact of crop losses (Zhou and Vilar-Zanón 2024). However, insurance mechanisms primarily compensate for yield losses in the year of the event and do not address potential carry-over effects on vine performance, nor do they offer guidance for post-event agronomic decision-making.
Given the perennial nature of grapevines and the significant economic value of grape and wine production, hailstorms present not only an immediate threat to yield and fruit quality, but also a potential risk to the sustainability and long-term productivity of vineyards. This issue has been thoroughly addressed in technical guidance for growers by many authors. The relevance of long-term hail effects as related to the viability of wood for renewal was reported in one study and the concept of post-hail adaptive pruning was introduced, denoting the capability of vines to replace damaged shoots with new, healthy shoots in the event of early-season hail (Dry 1986). Similarly, many technical notes reported on the importance of selecting the best canes in the winter following a hail event to ensure an adequate crop (Krstic et al. 2014, Ibbotson 2022, Sabbatini et al. 2024, Sabbatini 2025). Crucially, no studies have systematically quantified the effects of severe hail damage on grapevine performance in the subsequent growing season, nor have studies experimentally tested adaptive pruning or training system strategies aimed at mitigating these delayed effects. In particular, the consequences of hail-induced damage to perennial organs on bud fruitfulness, reserve accumulation, and yield recovery remain poorly understood, despite their critical importance for long-term costs and sustainability. Notably, in complex and spread trellis, the within-canopy spatial distribution of hail damage can vary considerably, particularly when hailstorms are accompanied by strong lateral winds. Under these conditions, injuries may be concentrated in specific canopy sectors, generating marked within-vine differences in wood damage and bud viability.
In this study, following a severe hailstorm that damaged the current-season crop of a commercial vineyard of Vitis vinifera L. cv. Glera, we sought to quantify the hailstorm’s impact on wood functionality and bud viability during winter. Additionally, we aimed to evaluate adaptive pruning strategies designed to mitigate potential yield losses in the subsequent growing season. We hypothesized that injuries could vary based on the local canopy spatial distribution and that temporarily modifying the trellis configuration or adjusting the pruning timing (based on the spatial distribution of bud damage assessed through winter bud analysis) could serve as effective strategies to reduce the long-term negative effects of destructive hail events.
Materials and Methods
Experimental site, vineyard design, and hailstorm description
The study occurred in a flat commercial vineyard of V. vinifera L. cv. Glera grafted onto Kober 5BB rootstock situated in Codognè (Treviso, Veneto, Italy; 45°88′N; 12°45′ E; 26 m asl). The vines (planted 2016) were arranged in rows oriented from north-northeast to south-southwest and were trained to a permanent single-high wire cordon system which bared six fruiting canes: three oriented toward the east-southeast and three toward the west-northwest (Figure 1), each pruned to six nodes, along with six two-node spurs, resulting in a total of 48 retained buds per vine at winter pruning. This training system typically lacks foliage wires and the vegetation is free.
(A) Vineyard and row orientation of the experimental site (located in Codognè, Italy). (B) The standard farm training system, consisting of a single-high wire cordon with six fruiting canes (three facing east-southeast and three facing west-northwest).
On 23 to 24 July 2023, a severe hailstorm with a predominant west-east wind direction completely destroyed the vineyard’s current-season crop, causing almost total defoliation, and inflicted severe damage to shoots and permanent structures (Supplemental Figure 1) (Atzeni 2023). At the time of the hailstorm, vines were at BBCH stage 79 (majority of berries touching; according to the phenological scale of Lorenz et al. [1995]). In response, two copper-based treatments were applied to facilitate wound sanitization and tissue healing. Standard pathogen management practices which were in place before the hailstorm continued throughout the subsequent growing season. The vineyard is equipped with a sub-fertirrigation system that seasonally delivers 60 kg of nitrogen/ha and 100% crop evapotranspiration from mid-July to the end of August, in the absence of significant rainfall. Daily mean temperature and rainfall were recorded by a weather station located near the vineyard. Thermal conditions were generally similar between years; cumulative growing degree days (base 10°C) reached 2111 in 2023 and 2165 in 2024 (Supplemental Figure 2). Total rainfall amounted to 933 mm in 2023 and 1168 mm in 2024.
Evaluation of wood and bud viability
In December 2023, a representative section of the vineyard displaying uniform injuries, comprised of 64 vines (16 vines along four rows), was chosen to evaluate the effect of the hailstorm on pruning wood, buds, and renewal candidates. Due to the predominantly west-east trajectory of the storm, the 1-yr-old wood on each vine was categorized into two exposure groups: east-facing wood (which included wood from east-southeast oriented fruiting canes and spurs) or west-facing wood (which included wood from west-northwest oriented fruiting canes and spurs) (Figure 1).
On 12 vines per row, three east-facing and three west-facing 1-yr-old canes were randomly sampled among those deemed suitable for future fruiting, based on vigor and orientation. For the evaluation of wood and bud viability, the 12 vines represented the replicates and the single canes represented the sub-replicates. Following a preliminary survey of the overall damage severity, nodes 1 to 6, along with the corresponding internode portion immediately below each node, were categorized based on visual assessment under an optical microscope (SZM-LED2, Optika). The injury categories, ranging from 1 (no external damage) through 6 (scarring with damaged or necrotic xylem and phloem, excised bud), are described (Table 1). For both cane orientations, the number of nodes with necrotic or excised buds was recorded for each node position. Subsequently, buds were dissected under an optical microscope to determine the number of inflorescence primordia per bud, as described previously (May and Antcliff 1973), according to node position and the canopy side of the cane. Buds were dissected progressively and inflorescence primordia per bud were counted. Bud fruitfulness was expressed on a per-bud basis and on a per-node basis; the latter calculation included necrotic or missing buds.
Classification of injuries found on 1-yr-old wood of Glera grapevines located at a vineyard in Codognè, Italy. The injuries were caused by a severe hailstorm that occurred on 23 to 24 July 2023. Different injury levels were assigned to portions of canes including a node and the below internode.
The nodes with 1 cm of the below- and above- internode tissue were then frozen, lyophilized, and utilized for the determination of nonstructural carbohydrates, following a prior process (Loewus 1952). After grinding, 10 mg of the sample was combined with 1.5 mL of 80% ethanol and maintained at 80°C for 1 hr. Following centrifugation at 12,000 rpm for 10 min, 50 μL of the supernatant was collected in 15-mL tubes and mixed with 5 mL of a solution containing sulfuric acid:water at a 70:30 ratio, 500 mg of anthrone, and 10 g of thiourea. After 15 min at 80°C, absorbance was measured at 620 nm for soluble sugars determination, using a JascoV-530 UV spectrophotometer (Jasco Analytical Instruments). For starch determination, the sample was washed with sodium acetate buffer. The sample and 0.5 mL of sodium acetate buffer were then maintained at 80°C for 1 hr. Subsequently, 1 mL of a solution containing amyloglucosidase and α-amylase in 0.05 M sodium acetate buffer was added as described (Chow and Landhäusser 2004). After maintaining the mixture at 50°C for 1 hr, 50 μL of the supernatant was collected and the previously described process was repeated.
Adaptive winter pruning
Starting in February 2024, and taking into account the west-east direction of the July hailstorm, the same plot of 64 vines was used to conduct an experiment aimed at evaluating the efficacy of post-hail adapted pruning strategies in a free-trellis, cane-pruned vineyard. The trial was arranged according to a completely randomized block design. The vines were divided into four blocks, each containing 16 plants (experimental units), and assigned to four treatments (four plants per treatment per block), as described (Table 2).
Description of pruning treatments performed on Glera grapevines located at a vineyard in Codognè, Italy, applied in the winter after a severe hailstorm that occurred on 23 to 24 July 2023. Treatments were performed on a permanent cordon that was pruned to retain six spurs and three fruiting canes each on the east and west sides of the canopy.
Immediately after pruning operations, visible injuries were assessed on all the treatments on two fruiting canes per vine across 12 vines for each treatment (one cane per canopy side, if applicable, based on the treatment). For each fruiting cane examined, each node and the internode below it were categorized as described (Table 3).
Classification of visual injuries on the six canes retained in field after winter pruning operations. Injuries were found on 1-yr-old wood of Glera grapevines located at a vineyard in Codognè, Italy, caused by a severe hailstorm that occurred on 23 to 24 July 2023.
On 14 May 2024 (phenological stage BBCH 61, onset of anthesis), shoot fruitfulness on the same canes was assessed by counting the number of inflorescences per shoot at any node position on the fruiting cane. Shoot fruitfulness was expressed both per shoot and per node, with the latter calculation accounting for any missing shoots.
At harvest (17 Sept 2024), yield was recorded separately for east-facing versus west-facing fruiting canes and spurs. Clusters were counted and their weights were calculated. Three clusters per vine were sampled and taken to the lab for fruit composition analysis. The berries were crushed and total soluble solids (TSS) were measured using a temperature-compensated desk refractometer. Meanwhile, pH and titratable acidity (TA) were determined by titration with 0.1 N sodium hydroxide to a pH endpoint of 8.2, expressed as g/L of tartaric acid equivalents.
Vine leaf area was estimated as described (Gatti et al. 2019). Before leaf fall, 24 shoots were randomly sampled and brought to the laboratory. In each sample, primary leaves and lateral shoot leaves were separated, detached, and counted. The total shoot leaf area from primary and lateral leaves was measured using a Li-COR Li3000A leaf area meter (LI-COR Biosciences). The average surface area of a primary leaf and a lateral leaf was then calculated. After leaf fall and before pruning, the total number of nodes on main and lateral shoots was counted for each vine. The total vine leaf area was then obtained by multiplying the number of nodes on primary and lateral shoots by their respective leaf areas. The leaf area-to-fruit ratio was then calculated for each vine. In winter 2024 during pruning, the total vine pruning weight was measured and the Ravaz index was calculated as the ratio between yield and 1-yr-old pruning wood.
Statistical analysis
The data set was initially analyzed to verify the analysis of variance (ANOVA) assumptions of homoscedasticity and normal distribution. Subsequently, the data underwent a one-way ANOVA (factor: pruning strategy; levels: T1, T2, T3, T4) using SPSS Statistics 24.0 (IBM). Tukey’s post-hoc comparison test was employed to evaluate the statistical significance between treatments (p < 0.05, 0.01, 0.005).
Results
Hailstorm injuries and wood/bud viability
In east-facing canes, most injuries were classified as damage class 2 (node 6 was the exception), showing a higher mean injury level of 2.9 (Figure 2A). Conversely, west-facing canes demonstrated a gradual increase in injury severity, starting at node 1 (with a mean class of 1.1) and peaking at node 4 (with a mean class of 3.4), before decreasing at nodes 5 and 6 (Figure 2A). Overall, west-facing canes exhibited significantly higher injury levels than east-facing canes at nodes 2, 3, 4, and 5, while no significant differences were observed at nodes 1 and 6.
Injury level (A), percent of necrotic and excised buds (B), number of inflorescence primordia per bud (C) and per node (including positions with excised/necrotic buds) (D), and node soluble sugars (E) and starch concentration (F), according to cane node position and cane orientation (east or west side of the canopy) in Glera grapevines located at a vineyard in Codognè, Italy that experienced a severe hailstorm on 23 to 24 July 2023. Bars represent standard errors (n = 48). Asterisks indicate significant differences between treatments at p < 0.05 (Student’s t-test).
In east-facing canes, the proportion of necrotic or excised buds was negligible across all node positions. In contrast, west-facing canes exhibited 25% necrotic or missing buds at nodes 3 and 5, with the incidence rising to 59% at node 4 (Figure 2B).
Bud fruitfulness, measured per bud, was generally consistent between east- and west-facing canes for nodes 1 through 5 (Figure 2C). A notable difference emerged only at node 6, where east-facing canes demonstrated higher bud fruitfulness, with 1.41 inflorescence primordia per bud compared to 0.70. However, when fruitfulness was assessed per node, east-facing canes exhibited a significantly greater number of inflorescence primordia per node at nodes 3, 4, 5, and 6, with differences ranging from +0.20 to +0.74 inflorescence primordia per node (Figure 2D).
East-facing canes demonstrated significantly higher concentrations of total soluble sugars (Figure 2E) and starch (Figure 2F) compared to west-facing canes across all node positions (nodes 1 to 6). On average, soluble sugars and starch concentrations were 61% and 103% higher, respectively, in east-facing canes than in west-facing canes.
Evaluation of adaptive winter pruning
In all treatments, the injury level on 1-yr-old wood progressively increased from node 1 to node 4, with no further rise observed from node 4 to node 6 (Figure 3A). At nodes 1, 2, and 4, there were no significant differences among treatments. However, at nodes 3 and 5, treatment T3 showed significantly higher injury levels compared to the other treatments. Despite these variations in injury severity, shoot fruitfulness expressed on a per-shoot basis was largely unaffected by treatment. Significant differences among treatments were only found at node position 3, where T2 and T4 demonstrated significantly higher shoot fruitfulness than T3 (+0.47 and +0.38 inflorescences per shoot, respectively), while T1 showed intermediate values (Figure 3B). When fruitfulness was expressed on a per-node basis, clearer differences among treatments became apparent (Figure 3C). At node 3, T3 had significantly fewer inflorescences than T1 (-0.38 inflorescences per node), which was lower than T2 and T4 (-0.19 inflorescences per node). At node 5, T4 had more inflorescences than both T1 and T3 (+0.24 and +0.37 inflorescences per node, respectively), while at node 6, T2 exhibited more inflorescences than T1 and T3 (+0.3 and +0.26 inflorescences per node, respectively).
Injury level (A), number of inflorescences per shoot (B), and number of inflorescences per cane node (C), according to cane node position, in Glera grapevines (located at a vineyard in Codognè, Italy) that were subjected to different winter pruning techniques after a severe summer hailstorm on 23 to 24 July 2023. Bars represent standard errors (n = 24). Asterisks indicate significant differences between treatments at p < 0.05 (Tukey’s honest significant difference test). T1, standard pruning: three fruiting canes pruned on the east-facing side of the canopy and three fruiting canes pruned on the west-facing side of the canopy; T2, adapted pruning: six fruiting canes pruned on the less damaged east-facing side of the canopy; T3, reference treatment: six fruiting canes pruned on the more severely damaged west-facing side of the canopy; T4, late pruning: same pruning layout as T1, but the pruning of the fruiting canes was performed at BBCH 09, allowing discrimination between viable and necrotic buds and pruning of the least damaged canes. Treatments were performed on a permanent cordon that was pruned to retain three fruiting canes each on the east and west sides of the canopy.
By the end of the season, no notable differences in vegetative growth were observed among the treatments, as evidenced by total vine leaf area and pruning weight (Table 4). At harvest, T4 had a significantly higher yield than T1, while T2 yielded more than T3. There were no significant differences between T1 and T2, T2 and T4, or T1 and T3 (Table 5). Furthermore, T4 had a significantly higher number of clusters per vine compared to both T1 and T3, with an increase of 6 and 5 clusters, respectively.
Leaf area and pruning weight of Glera grapevines located at a vineyard in Codognè, Italy. The grapevines were subjected to different winter pruning treatmentsa after a severe summer hailstorm that occurred on 23 to 24 July 2023.
Yield components, vine balance, and fruit composition of Glera grapevines located at a vineyard in Codognè, Italy. The grapevines were subjected to different winter pruning treatmentsa after a severe summer hailstorm that occurred on 23 to 24 July 2023. TSS, total soluble solids; TA, titratable acidity.
Treatments T2 and T4 showed the lowest leaf area-to-fruit ratios, whereas T3 exhibited a higher leaf area-to-fruit ratio than T1 (+14%). Consistently, T3 demonstrated a lower Ravaz index than T2 (-32%). Despite these variations in vine balance, no significant treatment effects were found on cluster weight, TSS, pH, or TA.
Yield distribution between the two canopy sides varied significantly across treatments (Table 6). In T1, 61% of the total yield was from east-facing fruiting canes, while west-facing fruiting canes contributed 28%. The yield from spurs was consistent among T1, T2, and T4, averaging 0.81 kg/vine and accounting for ~11% of the total crop. Conversely, T3 exhibited a notably higher spur-derived yield. As expected, T3 had the highest yield from west-facing fruiting canes. However, T4 produced a significantly larger crop from west-facing canes than T1 (+0.99 kg/vine), with no observed differences between these two treatments in yield from east-facing canes.
Yield from fruiting canes (east- and west-facing) and spurs in Glera grapevines located at a vineyard in Codognè, Italy. The grapevines were subjected to different winter pruning treatmentsa after a severe summer hailstorm that occurred on 23 to 24 July 2023.
When yield was expressed on a per-fruiting-cane basis, T2 and T4 exhibited the highest values, whereas T3 showed lower productivity compared to T1, with a difference of −0.33 kg/fruiting cane. In both T1 and T4, east-facing fruiting canes outperformed their west-facing counterparts, with increases of +0.72 and +0.42 kg/fruiting cane, respectively. However, in T4, west-facing canes yielded significantly more than those in T1 and T3, with differences of +0.33 and +0.30 kg/fruiting cane, respectively.
Discussion
Our findings offer the first quantitative evidence of the extent to which severe convective hailstorms can damage 1-yr-old wood and reproductive units in grapevines. Impacts from hail are not uniformly distributed within the canopy but can vary significantly depending on the wind direction during the event. Under lateral wind conditions, the canopy side directly exposed to the storm (west-facing in our case) experienced substantially greater damage than the opposite side (Figure 2A and 2B). Specifically, injury severity on 1-yr-old wood increased progressively from basal nodes to node 4, while nodes 5 and 6 were less affected than node 4, both in terms of mean injury level and the proportion of excised or necrotic buds.
The relatively limited damage observed at the basal nodes was expected, as these positions could generally be better shielded by multiple leaf layers and surrounding tissues. In contrast, the lower injuries at nodes 5 and 6 compared to node 4 were less expected. A plausible explanation for this pattern may lie in the canopy architecture and cluster distribution typical of cv. Glera (Tomasi et al. 2013). In this cultivar, inflorescences are primarily borne on nodes 3 to 5, and in the expanded free canopy configuration of the studied vineyard (Supplemental Figure 1), shoots in late July were already partially bent under the weight of the clusters. Consequently, nodes 3 to 5 were likely positioned at the uppermost and most exposed portion of the canopy during the hailstorm, which may explain their greater susceptibility to hailstone impact, whereas more distal nodes may have been partially shielded. Conversely, on the canopy side not directly facing the storm (east-facing in this study), injury levels were generally uniform from nodes 1 to 6 (Figure 2A) and corresponded on average to injury level 2, characterized by external scars without injury to xylem or phloem tissues. In this portion of the canopy, no buds were excised by the hailstorm.
Our findings highlight that wind dynamics during the event could create significant spatial heterogeneity of injuries within individual vines. Additionally, the results indicate that in a training system with a sprawl canopy, the timing of hailstorms within the growing season may lead to varying damage patterns. This variation arises from the interaction with the spatial canopy arrangement (e.g., mostly erect or decidedly downward), which is influenced by multiple factors such as cultivar habit, pruning length, cluster position along the shoot, and the presence or absence of prebloom shoot trimming.
Our data also indicate that despite the increased damage, bud fruitfulness did not significantly differ between the canopy sides when only healthy buds were considered. Shoot fruitfulness increased from node 1 to node 5 on both sides of the canopy, aligning with the well-established patterns of bud fertility according to node position in Glera (Tomasi et al. 2013) (Figure 2C). This is significant given the substantial defoliation caused by the hailstorm in the previous season. However, an important consideration is that in this study, the hailstorm occurred in late July, while flower induction and differentiation in grapevines typically occur from late spring to early summer (May 2000). Under our conditions, these processes were likely already completed by the time the hail-induced defoliation took place. Although we did not observe any effects on bud fruitfulness in our study, it remains possible that hail events occurring earlier in the season, along with the resulting defoliation, could negatively affect bud fruitfulness in the following season. When accounting for excised and necrotic buds, a noticeable reduction in the number of inflorescences per fruiting cane node is evident in west-facing canes (Figure 2D). In these canes, the number of inflorescence primordia per node was nearly halved from node 3 onward, closely mirroring the damage levels shown in Figure 2A and 2B.
The lower carbohydrate concentration observed at the third internode in west-facing canes compared to east-facing canes suggests that hail-induced defoliation may have affected local carbon availability and reserve allocation. This localized carbon depletion could potentially hinder initial shoot growth and inflorescence development from preformed primordia in the subsequent season (Srinivasan and Mullins 1981). However, previous studies suggest that early-season growth is primarily supported by whole-vine carbon reserves, with root-stored carbohydrates serving as the main source at these stages (May 2000, Zapata et al. 2004, Lebon et al. 2008). This implies that the localized reduction in carbohydrate availability at the cane level was likely offset by reserves from other vine organs, thus preventing any noticeable reduction in bud and shoot fruitfulness. Overall, our findings indicate that in the case of mid/late-season hail events, provided that bud necrosis or excision does not occur, no direct reduction in next season’s shoot fruitfulness should be expected, as the intrinsic fruitfulness of surviving buds remains unaffected. Instead, any decrease in inflorescence number, and consequently in yield, is primarily due to the loss of buds along the fruiting canes.
Given the results on bud viability, a marked difference in crop level among treatments would have been expected in subsequent season yield. However, injury levels only occasionally varied among treatments (Figure 3A) and the number of inflorescences per shoot remained largely comparable across treatments (Figure 3B). Notably, vine yield differed solely between T2 and T3, with T1 displaying intermediate values that did not significantly differ from either treatment (Table 5). Although basal buds of cv. Glera are naturally characterized by low fruitfulness, the relatively large cluster size of this cultivar may have contributed to the yield recovery observed in the present study. Even if a validation on other cultivars is crucial, these findings suggest a resilience and compensatory capacity of V. vinifera, even under severe damage conditions, as well as its ability to buffer the effects of localized injury and reduced carbohydrate allocation (Dry 1986). A crucial factor facilitating yield resumption was the training system used in this study, which relies on a permanent cordon where six relatively short (six nodes) fruiting canes are annually renewed. These canes are selected from a wide pool of potential candidates, including shoots from spurs, basal nodes of the previous season’s fruiting canes, and suckers from latent buds. This likely reduced the frequency of necrotic/excised buds on retained canes, compared to a layout requiring longer fruiting canes selected from fewer candidates. This is clearly supported by the comparison of the large differences between treatments observed in Figure 2A to 2D, with the minimal differences between treatments reported in Figure 3.
Would crop load recovery in the following season have been equally effective under alternative pruning systems that rely on longer fruiting canes or lack a permanent cordon with multiple spurs and latent buds (as seen in a classical simple Guyot)? While our study does not directly answer this question, our findings suggest that training systems based on spur pruning and/or short fruiting canes may be more effective in ensuring full crop load recovery after hail damage. In these systems, identifying and selecting reproductive units with minimal or no fatal bud damage could be inherently easier than in systems that depend on longer fruiting canes (e.g., Sylvoz) and/or lack a permanent cordon (e.g., simple Guyot, Umbrella Kniffin, Pergola, Tendone, and similar systems), given comparable hailstorm severity. Similarly, cultivars with low fruitfulness at basal nodes may be more susceptible to crop reduction in the year following hail, as short pruning is not a viable option (Poni et al. 2016, Kurtural and Fidelibus 2021).
A clear gradient in yield per fruiting cane, which decreases from T2 to T1 and further to T3, supports the aforementioned considerations (Table 6). Within T1, east-facing fruiting canes produced significantly higher yields than their west-facing counterparts. These findings suggest that the greater the proportion of canes with limited or no injury, the higher the crop load per fruiting cane that can be expected. Notably, partial compensation occurred at the spur level, aiding in the recovery of yield in T3 compared to T1. Although the six west-facing fruiting canes in T3 showed low productivity (similar to those in T1), the spur-derived yield in T3 was approximately double that of the other treatments.
The most effective adjustment for improving yield compared to the T1 control was the delayed winter pruning applied to T4 vines (Table 5). Postponing pruning until the bud-swelling stage is a well-established practice in cool-climate viticulture, where low winter temperatures can threaten bud viability (Howell and Wolpert 1978, Friend and Trought 2007, Keller and Mills 2007). This approach allows for a non-destructive, visual distinction between living swelling buds and necrotic buds, which can otherwise be challenging to discern (Howell and Wolpert 1978, Bordelon 2018). In this study, delayed pruning was specifically aimed at identifying and selecting canes with the highest number of viable buds within the first six nodes, while maintaining the original trellis configuration and a similar bud charge per vine. This strategy effectively enhanced the productivity of west-facing canes, increasing their yield from 0.63 in T1 to 0.96 kg/fruiting cane in T4 (Table 6), and raising the total vine crop load by 1.21 kg/vine (Table 5).
However, several constraints may limit the practical application of this technique. The time window available for pruning is significantly narrowed to the period between the onset of bud swelling (BBCH 05) and budbreak (BBCH 10 to 11) (Palliotti et al. 2017, Poni et al. 2022). Delays beyond this window can lead to undesirable outcomes such as mechanical damage to emerging shoots during pruning operations and potential reductions in inflorescence development due to carbohydrate limitations, as noted in studies on late winter pruning performed beyond BBCH 15 (Frioni et al. 2016, Silvestroni et al. 2018, Buesa et al. 2021). Additionally, the necessity to assess bud viability and selectively retain optimal canes could considerably extend the time required for pruning compared to standard winter operations. Consequently, delayed pruning is likely feasible only in small vineyards or when applied to select portions of larger vineyards.
Since neither canopy size nor total leaf area was influenced by the treatments (Table 4), the variations in the leaf-to-fruit ratio and Ravaz index mainly reflected differences in crop level (Table 5). Despite these changes in vine balance, no significant effects on grape composition were detected among the treatments, all of which showed relatively low grape TSS. This may be associated with the relatively low leaf-to-fruit ratio observed across treatments (Kliewer and Dokoozlian 2005). It is worth noting, however, that a later harvest (not feasible in our case due to the low TA levels) might have revealed further differences in grape sugars. Furthermore, based on existing literature, it cannot be ruled out that under different environmental conditions or in other cultivars, the observed variations in the leaf-to-fruit ratio and Ravaz index could affect sugar accumulation and/or the synthesis of secondary metabolites (Kliewer and Dokoozlian 2005, Teixeira et al. 2013, Poni et al. 2018).
Taken together, our findings highlight that following a hailstorm, attention should be devoted not only to the recovery of the current-season canopy and crop, but also to the viability of renewal wood and buds that determine productivity in the subsequent year. Post-hail vineyard management should therefore be guided by the spatial distribution of damage within the canopy rather than by uniform pruning approaches, particularly when hailstorms are associated with strong lateral winds.
Conclusion
Severe hailstorms can cause significant and uneven damage to 1-yr-old wood and buds in grapevines, and the canopy sections exposed to the wind can be disproportionately affected. However, data demonstrate that when these severe hail events occur from mid- to late-season, they do not seem to affect the predetermined fruitfulness of the surviving buds. This suggests that any subsequent reduction in yield is mainly due to bud mortality rather than to physiological limitations in reproductive potential.
Under these conditions, grapevines demonstrate a remarkable ability to adapt, especially when pruning systems allow for a broad and flexible selection of bearing units. Among the strategies evaluated, delayed pruning has proven effective in enhancing yield recovery by allowing for the selection of viable buds, although its practical application is limited by operational constraints. Looking ahead, training systems that depend on long cane-pruning may be more susceptible than those based on spur pruning, due to decreased selectivity. Overall, these findings highlight the importance of tailoring post-hail pruning strategies to the spatial distribution of damage within the canopy and provide a physiological and agronomic basis for improving vineyard resilience to increasingly frequent severe hail events.
CRediT Authorship Contributions
PB: Software; PB, HT, MB: Data Curation, Investigation; PB, TF: Writing - Original Draft; HT, MB, SP: Writing - Review & Editing; SP: Formal Analysis, Resources; SP, TF: Validation; TF: Conceptualization, Funding Acquisition, Methodology
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Supplemental Data
The following supplemental materials are available for this article in the Supplemental tab above:
Supplemental Figure 1 (A) Effects of a destructive hailstorm occurring in the experimental vineyard (located in Codognè, Italy) on the night between 23 and 24 July 2023. (B) An enlarged image of the injuries incurred by growing shoots and permanent wood structures of Glera grapevines.
Supplemental Figure 2 Seasonal weather dynamics across two growing seasons. The orange line indicates daily mean temperature and the blue bars represent daily precipitation. Temperature and rainfall data were recorded by a weather station located near the study vineyard (in Codognè, Italy).
Data Availability
The data underlying this study are available on request from the corresponding author.
Footnotes
We thank Azienda Agricola Bonicelli for the technical support and topic discussion.
Bonicelli PG, Tiwari H, Bartczak MH, Poni S and Frioni T. 2026. Severe hail effects on grapevine bud viability and next-season recovery: Implications for adaptive pruning. Am J Enol Vitic 77:0770025. DOI: 10.5344/ajev.2026.26016
By downloading and/or receiving this article, you agree to the Disclaimer of Warranties and Liability. If you do not agree to the Disclaimers, do not download and/or accept this article.
- Received April 2026.
- Accepted July 2026.
- Published online October 2026
This is an open access article distributed under the CC BY 4.0 license.









